Should we elect our Supreme Court Justices?

If we made “America From Scratch” today, would we elect our Supreme Court Justices and should they have term limits?

The right to an abortion, the right to marry, the Dred Scott decision—some of the United States’ most controversial, historic and influential legal decisions have been made for us by a group of people we didn’t get to choose. The U.S. Supreme Court is one of the tenets of our democracy, but is the way these justices are put in place very democratic? Host Toussaint Morrison talks with Hamline University professor of political science David Schultz and wonders: If we started America from scratch today, would we elect our Supreme Court justices?

Join the conversation!

Share your thoughts in the YouTube comments. Be sure to subscribe to the “America From Scratch” YouTube channel while you’re there!

Want to dig even deeper on these topics? Listen to our podcast!

“America From Scratch” is produced by Rewire for PBS Digital Studios as part of the Twin Cities PBS initiative “In It Together.” Made possible with funding from The Corporation for Public Broadcasting.

All Videos